Equations · 5 min read · 4 linked sources
Mifflin-St Jeor vs Harris-Benedict: Which Equation Should You Trust?
Two century-spanning formulas, one purpose. Why VitalMetric uses Mifflin-St Jeor, and how much error to expect from any prediction.
Two equations, two eras
The Harris-Benedict equation was published in 1918 from measurements of a few hundred mostly young, normal-weight adults. It was revised in 1984, and both versions are still widely used. The Mifflin-St Jeor equation was published in 1990 from about 500 adults, including many with overweight and obesity, which better reflects today's population.
Both predict resting energy needs from weight, height, age and sex. They differ in their coefficients, and that is enough to produce noticeably different outputs for the same person.
What the evidence comparison found
A 2005 systematic review by the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics (Frankenfield and colleagues) compared common prediction equations against measured resting metabolic rate. Mifflin-St Jeor was the most likely to predict within 10 percent of measured values in both non-obese and obese adults, while the Harris-Benedict equation tended to overestimate more often.
Within 10 percent is still a range
Even the best equation misses by more than 10 percent for a meaningful share of people. For someone with a true resting rate of 1,600 calories, that means the prediction could plausibly be anywhere from about 1,440 to 1,760. Older adults, very muscular people and some ethnic groups are less well represented in the original datasets.
About the sex input
These equations were derived from data labelled male or female, so they need one of those two inputs to produce a number. If you are transgender or intersex, or using hormone therapy, neither option may describe your physiology precisely. A clinician who knows your history can help you interpret the estimate, and tracking your real-world trend matters even more.
How VitalMetric uses it
We use Mifflin-St Jeor for BMR, then multiply by your chosen activity factor to estimate TDEE. The activity factors themselves add another layer of uncertainty, because people often overestimate how active they are. If you are unsure between two levels, choose the lower one and adjust after a few weeks.
Sources & further reading
These links support the guide and let you check the underlying research or guidance. Listing a source does not mean it reviewed or endorses VitalMetric.
- Mifflin MD et al. A new predictive equation for resting energy expenditure. Am J Clin Nutr, 1990
- Frankenfield D et al. Comparison of predictive equations for RMR. J Am Diet Assoc, 2005
- Harris JA, Benedict FG. A biometric study of basal metabolism in man. PNAS, 1918
- Roza AM, Shizgal HM. The Harris-Benedict equation reevaluated. Am J Clin Nutr, 1984
Educational content for adults. Not medical advice and not medically reviewed. Talk to a qualified clinician about your individual needs.